Things will be a bit choppy blogging-wise in the next couple of weeks, so I should blog while there's still time. Even though I am a little tired, I'm hoping the subject matter will pep me up – after all, it's not every day we get a new Jane Austen film.
My feelings towards the new film adaptation of Sense and Sensibility (directed by Georgia Oakley) were ambivalent and my expectations weren't that high. The trailers seemed to be going for a more "down-to-earth" look than Ang Lee's 1995 film, a look that wasn't that appealing. At the same time, scenes from the trailers looked mildly anachronistic, what with the Dashwood sisters tearing around outdoors, their plentiful hair streaming in the wind, as if they were Catherine Earnshaw. However, after a slow start – and let's face it, the start of this story is rather slow – I found that this adaptation quite grew on me.
For one thing, unlike the TV adaptation by Andrew Davies, the film actually offered a different spin on Austen's novel than Ang Lee's (and Emma Thompson's), while still being respectful towards its source material. There were changes to the story, but I felt they were made not to "appeal to a modern audience" or some such guff, but in order for the film to flow more smoothly. Much as I love the 1995 film, there are some lulls in it – I remember one awkward scene between a bowing Edward and a curtsying Elinor where I felt especially sorry for the boyfriends who had been dragged to see it. This new adaptation cuts to the chase with a little more alacrity, while still keeping the important story beats.
The changes to Edward's back story with Lucy were particularly welcome, as it made his behaviour a bit more comprehensible. I did wonder, though, where the secrecy came in in this new version of events. Edward's family should already have been aware of what he had set out to do, and there was no real reason for Elinor not to tell Marianne the whole story. All the same, the romance between Elinor and Edward was the best part of the film: Daisy Edgar Jones's Elinor and George MacKay's Edward have real chemistry.
Another spin on the story I enjoyed was how Margaret, the youngest sister, was handled. The loveable moppet of the 1995 version is unforgettable, which is why I appreciate when an adapter tries something new instead of using the exact same approach like Andrew Davies did. If I remember rightly, Margaret in the book is actually in her early teens or thereabouts, and this film's Margaret is closer to that age than the 1995 one were. She has her boisterous moments, but all in all she is less of a child and more of a "tween" who has already started to think about her future romantic prospects (she declared that she will marry someone rich and if Marianne doesn't want Brandon, she'll have him if he's prepared to wait for a couple of years). She's still fun, but in her own way.
As for Marianne's part of the story it was – all right. I believed in Esmee Creed Miles's portrayal, and did not mind that the time spent on her whirlwind romance with Willoughby was shortened. But as for her suitors, I preferred the obviously dashing Greg Wise as Willoughby and Alan Rickman as a near-flawless Colonel Brandon in the 1995 version (his only fault was that he was perhaps a little too attractive for the part).
Frank Dillane's Willoughby is still handsome, but he doesn't cut the same faux-heroic figure as Wise, so it becomes less apparent why Marianne (and the rest of the family, let's not forget) are taken in by him. He's believable as a creep, but as loath as I am to accept any excuses for Willoughby's behaviour, I do think Wise's nuanced portrayal was more interesting. Brandon is played by Herbert Nordrum, who has the right solemn vibe for the part, but struggles to keep his speech as accent-free as possible, which doesn't give him much opportunity to emote. One can see why Marianne wasn't duly impressed with this grump at first.
All the same, this is a different and valid way of interpreting Marianne's romances. I do appreciate that Oakley hasn't set out to do the same thing as Ang Lee's film all over again.
There are some changes I can't quite understand. Why is John Middleton no longer Mrs Dashwood's brother? Does the cottage really have to be quite so dilapidated? On the other hand, I have no problem with the film changing John Dashwood from greedy to henpecked, partly because Tom Brooke is such a good character actor. On the subject of character actors, Fiona Shaw has a ball as Mrs Jennings, and is enjoyable to watch, though I confess I still prefer Elizabeth Spriggs.
In short, I was pleasantly surprised by the new Sense and Sensibility film. If you only see one Sense and Sensibility adaptation, then obviously go for the 1995 one. But if you're an Austen fan and enjoy watching different adaptations of the same book, I think you'll appreciate this one.
